Facebook Instagram Linkedin Twitter Youtube
  • Media/Marketing
    • Ad Asia Lahore 2019
    • Case Studies
    • CEO Stories
    • Effie Awards Pakistan
    • Events
    • Interviews
    • OOH Ads
    • Print Ads
    • Research
    • Research Articles
    • TV Ads
  • News
    • Jaffar Express Hijack
    • Pakistan
  • VeryFilmi
    • Celebrities
    • Celebrity Profiles
    • TV
  • Sports
    • Champions Trophy 2025
    • HBL PSL 9
    • ICC Cricket World Cup
    • PSL X
    • World Cup ’24
  • Tech
    • Gadget
    • Gaming
    • How To
    • Mobile
    • Social
  • Auto
  • OP-ED
  • Lifestyle
    • Beauty
    • Campus Stories
    • Culture
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Health
    • Movies
    • Music
    • Travel
  • World
  • اردو
Search
Sign in
Welcome! Log into your account
Forgot your password? Get help
Password recovery
Recover your password
A password will be e-mailed to you.
Brandsynario
  • Media/Marketing
    • AllAd Asia Lahore 2019Case StudiesCEO StoriesEffie Awards PakistanEventsInterviewsOOH AdsPrint AdsResearchResearch ArticlesTV Ads
      Dubai Islamic Bank

      Dubai Islamic Bank Partners with JazzCash to Enhance Digital Financial Solutions…

      realme

      Realme 14 Series To Debut On July 14th With Pakistan’s First…

      TCL

      TCL Launches Its All-New Washing Machines – Mehnat Kam, Safayi Zyada….

      Karachi port

      Karachi Port Trust Delegation Visits Cbd Punjab To Explore Investment And…

  • News
    • AllJaffar Express HijackPakistan
      the-vertical-unveils-pakistans-first-ever-shared-ownership-model-for-commercial-property

      The Vertical Unveils Pakistan’s First-Ever Shared Ownership Model for Commercial Property

      women-among-149-arrested-in-call-centre-scam-in-pakistan

      Women Among 149 Arrested in Call Centre Scam in Pakistan

      a-citizen-has-filed-a-petition-in-a-lower-court-to-register-a-case-regarding-the-death-of-model-and-actress-humaira-asghar-ali-the-petition-states-that-her-death-was-not-natural-and-alleges-murder-t

      Petition Filed Over Model Humaira Asghar’s Death

      pvara-pakistan-moves-toward-formal-crypto-regulation

      With PVARA, Pakistan Moves Toward Formal Crypto Regulation

  • VeryFilmi
    • AllCelebritiesCelebrity ProfilesTV

      The Cursed Side of Lollywood: Mental Health, Isolation and the Grim…

      Is Filmmaker Jami Being Jailed for Exposing an Alleged Abuser?

      Every Celebrity That Has Been On Ozempic

      Hania Aamir and Bilal Abbas Khan Pair Up for Maiden Collaboration

  • Sports
    • AllChampions Trophy 2025HBL PSL 9ICC Cricket World CupPSL XWorld Cup ’24
      mike-hesson-reaffirms-faith-in-babar-azam-rizwan

      Mike Hesson Confirms His Role In Pakistan’s Team Selection

      mike-hesson-shuts-down-babar-azam-wicket-keeping-rumours

      Mike Hesson Shuts Down Babar Azam’s Wicket-Keeping Rumours

      wiaan-mulder-reveals-conversation-with-brian-lara

      Wiaan Mulder Reveals Conversation With Brian Lara After Record-Breaking 367*

      king-kar-lega-hasan-ali-explains-the-sentiment

      ‘King Kar Lega’: Hasan Ali Explains the Sentiment Behind the Viral…

  • Tech
    • AllGadgetGamingHow ToMobileSocial

      Is This the Future of Foldable Phones? Meet the Galaxy Z…

      Huawei Seeks AI Chip Deals in Middle East, Southeast Asia

      what-is-black-box-ai-and-how-does-it-work

      What is Black Box AI and How Does it Work?

      an-ai-chef-is-taking-over-a-dubai-kitchen

      An AI Chef is Taking Over a Dubai Kitchen!

  • Auto
    • Honda Car Prices Increased Due to NEV levy, Effective July 1,…

      hyundai-pakistan-increased-their-prices-due-to-nev-levy

      Hyundai Pakistan Increased Their Prices Due to NEV Levy

      changan-increases-price-across-all-models

      After Suzuki and Toyota, Changan Increases Price Across All Models

      suzuki-to-raise-car-prices-from-july-1-following-gst-hike

      Suzuki to Raise Car Prices from July 1, Following GST Hike

      trumps-auto-parts-tariffs-affecting-the-broader-economy

      How are Trump’s Auto Parts Tariffs Affecting the Broader Economy?

  • OP-ED
    • why-everyone-wants-to-glow-up-but-not-grow-up

      Why Everyone Wants to Glow Up But Not Grow Up

      reality-of-call-centers-in-pakistan-call-centre-or-fraud-centres

      Call Centres or Fraud Centres: Reality of Call Centres in Pakistan

      sylvia-plaths-fig-tree-perspective-and-how-itresonating-with-gen-z

      Sylvia Plath’s Fig Tree Perspective and How It’s Resonating With Gen…

      monsoon-rains-expected-in-karachi-this-weekend-but-is-the-city-ready

      Monsoon Rains Expected in Karachi this Weekend — But is the…

      as-fo-refers-dr-aafias-case-to-agp-lets-revisit-the-past

      As FO Refers Dr Aafia Siddiqui Case to AGP, Let’s Revisit…

  • Lifestyle
    • AllBeautyCampus StoriesCultureFashionFoodHealthMoviesMusicTravel
      does-redbrick-pizzeria-really-serve-the-best-pizza-in-karachi

      Does Redbrick Pizzeria Really Serve the Best Pizza in Karachi?

      skylrk-is-here-biebers-new-fashion-era-begins

      Justin Bieber Launches a New Clothing Brand: Skylrk

      an-ai-chef-is-taking-over-a-dubai-kitchen

      An AI Chef is Taking Over a Dubai Kitchen!

      historical-stories-behind-the-biggest-cultural-monuments-of-pakistan

      Historical Stories Behind the Biggest Cultural Monuments of Pakistan

  • World
    • xpanceos-smart-contact-lens-could-replace-all-your-devices-and-just-raised-250m-to-do-it

      XPANCEO’s Smart Contact Lens Could Replace All Your Devices

      DeepSeek vs ChatGPT: Which AI is Better?

      ferrero-set-to-buy-wk-kellogg-for-3-billion

      Ferrero Set to Buy WK Kellogg for $3 Billion

      everything-you-need-to-know-about-p-diddys-trial-jay-z-and-beyonce

      Everything You Need to Know About Diddy’s Trial, Jay Z and…

      lee-jung-jae-ends-squid-game-with-powerful-words

      Lee Jung-jae Ends Squid Game With Heavy Words

  • اردو
Home News Pakistan India, Pakistan Ex-Spies Spark Furore with Secret Book Project
  • News
  • Pakistan

India, Pakistan Ex-Spies Spark Furore with Secret Book Project

By
AFP
-
Jun 7, 2018
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
WhatsApp

    It began with hushed conversations in hotels dotted around Asia, and resulted in a nearly unthinkable book: “Spy Chronicles”, a secret collaboration by former intelligence chiefs of India and Pakistan that has caused uproar in Islamabad.

    The book, published last month, was co-authored by retired General Asad Durrani, head of Pakistan’s Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) between 1990 and 1992, and his counterpart A.S Dulat, who led India’s Research and Analysis Wing (RAW) from 1999-2000.

    They are the two most powerful intelligence agencies in the neighboring countries, who have been fierce adversaries since Partition in 1947.

    “The CIA and the KGB had lines of communication, even at the height of the Cold War. But ISI and RAW don’t,” Indian journalist Aditya Sinha, who facilitated the conversations, told AFP.

    The project, which he said was conducted covertly, took two and a half years to complete.

    It required four marathon sessions in neutral territory — Istanbul, Bangkok and Kathmandu — organized on the sidelines of meetings between Indian and Pakistani officials seeking to hold dialogue.

    “We did not wear overcoats or glasses. But the two chiefs have a lifetime habit of being discreet,” Sinha said.

    “We met in each other’s hotel rooms. In (Kathmandu), we found a corner of a lobby. If somebody came near our corner, everybody would stop talking.”

    Among the topics discussed are longstanding allegations that Pakistan uses proxies in India and Afghanistan, such as the Afghan Taliban and the Haqqani network, and provides them safe haven.

    The US has repeatedly demanded that Islamabad take action against militancy. In the book, Durrani asserts that — if the fighters are indeed in Pakistan — doing so would be a “disaster”.

    “(By) going against them, we would not only turn some more of our own people against us but also these groups who have never harmed us,” he writes.

    Durrani, who was no longer Pakistan’s top spy in 2011 when Osama bin Laden was killed in a US raid in the military town of Abbottabad, also suggests that Islamabad probably knew where the Al Qaeda leader was hiding — though he provides no smoking gun.

    “Cooperating with the US to eliminate a person regarded by many in Pakistan as a ‘hero’ could have embarrassed the government,” he writes.

    – ‘Strong reaction’ – 

    The two men also discuss Kashmir, the disputed Himalayan region which has fuelled two wars between India and Pakistan, including the ongoing insurgency on the Indian side of the territory.

    Dulat, who is critical of Indian policies in Kashmir, repeats claims that Pakistan has a hand in the insurgency.

    In India, where New Delhi’s Kashmir policy has been severely and widely criticised, “Spy Chronicles” received a fairly positive reception and Dulat gave televised interviews.

    But in Pakistan, Durrani’s claims — which often go against the official line — were swiftly vilified.

    Adding to the uproar, a fake Twitter account posting polarising comments was created in his name. It has since been disabled.

    Late last month, the former spy chief was summoned by the military to explain himself. He was also forbidden to leave the country.

    He was not given permission to write the book, military spokesman Major General Asif Ghafoor told a press conference on Monday, adding: “When you commit a mistake there will be a strong reaction”.

    – Pakistan military under pressure – 

    In Islamabad, the book’s release comes at an inauspicious time for the military.

    In mid-April, former Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif suggested that Pakistani militants were involved in the deadly 2008 Mumbai attacks, provoking a firestorm just months before nationwide elections which the military has pledged to respect.

    Meanwhile a growing grassroots movement in the northwest is pushing back against the military’s alleged support for militants along the Afghan border and demanding an end to enforced disappearances.

    “When this book went out, there was a lot of political pressure. The army had to do something,” says former Pakistani general Saad M. Khan.

    Pakistan, which has been ruled for nearly half its 70-year history by the military, is a “national security state” which “looks at all subjects from a paranoid angle”, Khan said.

    For ex-general Talat Masood, Durrani “crossed certain limits” and “should have projected Pakistan in a better light”.

    The usually outspoken Durrani has not talked to the media.

    But Dulat says he “can’t understand” the furore.

    “After so many years in the business, you know what to say and what to not say. Both of us knew that,” he told AFP by telephone.

    The book was written, he says, to show it is possible to progress the Pakistan-India relationship.

    But Pakistan’s reaction shows that change “remains a dream”.

    Facebook
    Twitter
    Pinterest
    WhatsApp
      AFP
      AFP
      https://www.brandsynario.com/
      Brandsynario is a unique, interactive online publishing house that presents integrated and updated news and information concentrating on brands’ marketing activities.

      Facebook Instagram Linkedin Twitter Youtube
      • Home
      • About Us
      • Write for Us
      • Careers
      • Advertise
      • Privacy Policy
      • Contact Us
      © 2025 Brandsynario