Karachi loves drama. But nobody expected it to come from masalas.
What began as a straightforward campaign by Shan Foods quickly spiralled into one of the most entertaining marketing face-offs the city has seen in years. Then, just when the narrative felt complete, Imtiaz Super Market stepped in and rewrote the script entirely.
This is no longer just advertising. It is storytelling, psychology, and street-level theatre all rolled into one.
The Opening Move: Shan Plays the Numbers Game
Shan did what market leaders typically do. It leaned into dominance.
Its billboard, “Karachi main 9/10 logon ka intikhab,” was not trying to be clever. It did not need to be. It was built on one of marketing’s oldest psychological triggers, the bandwagon effect. If most people are choosing something, it must be right.
And in Pakistan’s kitchen culture, that logic works. Shan has long positioned itself as the default, the safe choice for everyday cooking. The ad reinforced that authority rather than challenging it.
Then came Falak Foods with a move that instantly changed the tone of the conversation.
Instead of competing head-on, Falak placed its billboard right next to Shan’s and responded with a single line: “1/10 bano… kuch naya karo.”
That line did something subtle but powerful. It did not deny Shan’s claim. It reframed it.
Suddenly, being part of the 90 percent was no longer reassuring. It felt predictable. Safe. Maybe even boring.
And the 10 percent? That became aspirational. Different. Bold.
This is textbook challenger-brand strategy. You do not beat the leader by proving them wrong. You make their strength feel like a weakness.

The Real Genius: Location, Not Just Copy
Falak’s move was not just about words. It was about placement.
By positioning its ad right next to Shan’s, Falak turned two separate campaigns into a single conversation.
Consumers were no longer seeing ads in isolation. They were seeing a dialogue unfold in real time. The billboards felt like a chat thread, with Shan making a claim and Falak replying with a punchline.
This is what marketers call competitive positioning, but in Karachi, it simply felt like trolling done right.

And Then… Imtiaz Walks In
Just when the internet had picked sides, Imtiaz Super Market joined the conversation with perfect timing.
“Ana tou Imtiaz hi hai… kiun k Imtiaz hi deta hai masalon pe best prices.”
No attack. No defense. Just a clever pivot.
Instead of engaging in the 9/10 vs 1/10 debate, Imtiaz reframed the entire question. It shifted focus from brand preference to purchasing behaviour.
Because at the end of the day, whether you are team Shan or team Falak, you still need to buy your masalas from somewhere.
That “somewhere” is exactly where Imtiaz positioned itself.

















Brandsynario
Veryfilmi