Karachi’s e-challan system has led to strong public reactions as many citizens say the fines are too high and the government should first fix the city’s broken roads.
Traffic officials, however, say the strict penalties are necessary to control violations and restore safety on the roads.
DIG Traffic Peer Muhammad Shah said that heavy fines are meant to stop violations and should not be compared to people’s financial limits. He said, “breaking traffic rules is not a basic necessity that one must repeat again and again.”
Speaking at the Karachi Chamber of Commerce & Industry (KCCI), he said Karachi’s traffic problems are the result of people ignoring basic rules. According to him, “As a society, we no longer consider wrong as wrong. People break signals or ride without helmets without even feeling guilty.”
He added that after the launch of the e-challan system, WhatsApp groups of Chhipa and Edhi in camera-covered areas “have gone silent” because accidents in those zones have reduced.
DIG Shah said Karachi earlier saw three traffic deaths every day, but after digital enforcement, the number has dropped to two. He said, “That means we are saving around 30 lives a month. Our target is to bring fatalities down to one death per day – saving 60 lives each month.”
He also shared a story of a lawyer who once gave a judge Rs500 in advance for a Rs100 fine because he expected to repeat the same behaviour. Shah said this shows how small penalties lose their purpose.
The DIG said 11 Sahulat Centres now give first-time offenders a one-time waiver. Only a small part of the city currently has smart cameras, but early results show drivers are becoming more careful.
He said that if someone wears a helmet on Shahrah-e-Faisal due to cameras, “gradually he will stop removing it even in non-camera zones.”
He warned that damaging number plates or using fake plates is a criminal act and will lead to arrest. Vehicles with fake or untransferred plates will be blacklisted across police and excise systems.
Need For Better Signal System
DIG Shah said Karachi needs at least 400 smart traffic signals to manage congestion. He explained that the city cannot depend on long open corridors because they simply shift traffic from one place to another.
He said Karachi requires “intelligent signals that respond to real-time traffic, not fixed timers.” One signal costs around Rs9 million. He said the Traffic Engineering Bureau must be activated, but the department still lacks engineers and funding.
The DIG also announced that dumpers must now have trackers. Any dumper without an approved tracker will face a Rs100,000 fine and an FIR. He said, “Without tracking, we would basically be giving them a licence to kill.”
Public Reaction And Criticism
Many people say the AI-based e-challan system is unfair because the city’s roads are in very bad condition and daily travel is already difficult.
They say fines only add more pressure on citizens who are already struggling with inflation and poor infrastructure.
A resident, Ehtesham Khan, who recently got a Rs5,000 e-challan, told The Express Tribune that the city is becoming “unbearable” for ordinary people while the privileged face no issues. He said inequality has reached its highest point in Karachi, and the elite “get every piece of the cake.”
He said the fine “will eat a big chunk of my salary.” According to him, the authorities should repair the roads first and then punish violations.
He said, “My simple wish is this: give us roads first and then fine me if I break any traffic rule.”
His comments reflect what many Karachi residents feel, especially as they deal with potholes, broken signals, unfinished underpasses and rising taxes.
Many say the system feels unfair when basic infrastructure remains neglected.
Stay tuned to Brandsynario for latest news and updates

















Brandsynario
Veryfilmi