The Supreme Court of Pakistan upheld Zahir Jaffer’s death sentence for the 2021 murder of Noor Mukadam on 20 May 2025, aiming to close one of the nation’s most shocking criminal cases. However, public outrage has resurfaced following an additional note released by Justice Ali Baqar Najafi.
In his note, Justice Najafi reaffirmed his support for the verdict but described Noor and Zahir’s so-called “live-in relationship” as a social vice.
He stated that such arrangements “defy not only the law of the land but also the personal law” under Sharia and called them a “direct revolt” against God. He further warned young people about the “horrible consequences” of such relationships and urged social reformers to take notice.
Court Rulings and Sentences
In the original ruling, the Supreme Court confirmed Jaffer’s death penalty for murder under Section 302 PPC. His death sentence for rape was commuted to life imprisonment, and his kidnapping conviction was reduced from 10 years to one year. Jaffer’s former staff members, including the watchman and gardener, were released, with the court ruling that time already served was sufficient. The bench was headed by Justice Hashim Kakar, with Justices Najafi and Ishtiaq Ibrahim.
Justice Najafi’s framing of the case as a moral issue triggered strong criticism on social media.
Senior journalist Mariana Baabar questioned the relevance of lifestyle choices to the crime, asking: “Does Islam allow beheading of na-mahram?” Researcher Fauzia Yazdani highlighted that the central issue was “murder,” not personal relationships.
Defenders of judicial impartiality stressed that courts should focus on evidence and the severity of crimes, not moral judgments or policing lifestyles, especially when such choices are not part of the charges.
Critics warn that these comments risk shifting blame onto victims and could undermine public trust in the justice system.
Despite the backlash, the Supreme Court’s legal verdict remains unchanged, but the social repercussions of Justice Najafi’s commentary are likely to continue long after the court proceedings have ended.
Stay tuned to Brandsynario for latest news and updates

















Brandsynario
Veryfilmi