The countdown to PSL 10 is on, and excitement is sky-high. But just before the first ball is bowled, controversy has knocked on the door. And this time, it’s not about a dropped catch or a selection snub—it’s about a voice behind the mic.
Salman Butt in the Commentary Box
Former Pakistan captain Salman Butt, who was once banned for his role in the 2010 spot-fixing scandal, has been added to the PSL 10 commentary panel. But not everyone’s thrilled about it.
According to reports, franchise owners weren’t on board with this decision. They reportedly sent a joint letter to the PCB, requesting that no individual with a history of unethical conduct—like fixing—be allowed in the commentary team.
While the letter didn’t name Butt directly, the message was clear. But here’s the twist—the PCB didn’t back down. Just a day later, they unveiled a star-studded commentary panel, and yes, Butt’s name was right there.
Read More: Is Ihsanullah Joining Peshawar Zalmi for PSL?
In response to the franchises’ concerns, the league reportedly argued that Butt will only do Urdu commentary, which they suggested wouldn’t have much international exposure.
That explanation, honestly, feels a bit weak. Fixing scandals don’t need subtitles to tarnish reputations. And this is the landmark 10th edition of the PSL—we’re talking about legacy here.
But Wait—Wasn’t Amir Involved, Too?
This brings us to the elephant in the room—Mohammad Amir. He was also part of the 2010 scandal, along with Mohammad Asif and Salman Butt. Yet, Amir has been playing in the PSL since the very first season.
He spent eight years with the Karachi Kings before moving to the Quetta Gladiators. And let’s not forget, he even played for Pakistan again after serving his ban.
Read More: Sarfaraz Ahmed Puts Retirement Rumors to Rest
Yes, Amir was only 17 back then and reportedly acted under pressure from his captain. But that doesn’t completely erase his accountability. If redemption is an option for one, shouldn’t it be for all?
This situation has opened up a bigger debate: How do we, as fans and stakeholders, define second chances in cricket? Are we okay with watching a fixer bowl at 140 km/h but not okay with him discussing a powerplay on-air?
Maybe the franchises have a point about protecting the league’s image. But consistency matters too. If we’ve forgiven Amir—and even celebrated his comeback—then why is Butt’s voice such a big problem?
Stay tuned to Brandsynario for the latest news and updates.